Deal of The Day! Hurry Up, Grab the Special Discount - Save 25% - Ends In 00:00:00 Coupon code: SAVE25
Welcome to Pass4Success

- Free Preparation Discussions

ISTQB CTAL-TTA Exam - Topic 5 Question 22 Discussion

Posted by Dean on Sep 19, 2024 at 11:12 AM

You are working on a complex systems integration project that will soon be deployed to the production environment. This system is replacing a system that was popular with the users and had no outstanding non-functional issues. There are multiple components that interact and these have been developed by various development and testing groups including some outsourced groups. You will be leading the performance testing effort. Although you would prefer to have a dedicated test system for this effort, you will have to use the production system. You can do this testing at a low usage time, but there will be some users on the system and you will be using real data for the tests. You are now planning your performance testing. Unfortunately, there are no requirements for the performance requirements of the system. How do you determine the acceptable performance levels for the various operational profiles?

Suggested Answer: A

Given the absence of defined performance requirements for the new system, a practical approach is to use the performance metrics of the legacy system as a benchmark. This method is beneficial as it provides a clear, historical baseline of what users are accustomed to and accept as satisfactory performance. Benchmarking against the legacy system ensures the new system meets or exceeds the performance levels that users already find acceptable, which can facilitate smoother acceptance and transition to the new system.


Get Premium CTAL-TTA Questions as Interactive Web-Based Practice Test or PDF Real Exam Format Detailed Explanations Instant Access Get Your Practice Test
31 comments · newest first
ST
Stephaine 10 months ago
Surprised there's no performance requirements at all!
RO
Rolande 11 months ago
Industry benchmarks could be useful, but are they relevant?
GL
Glory 11 months ago
I think we need updated requirements from the analysts.
CA
Carli 11 months ago
Definitely ask users for their expectations!
NI
Nickolas 11 months ago
Legacy system performance is a solid benchmark!
TR
Troy 12 months ago
Using industry standard benchmarks sounds familiar, but I wonder if they really apply to our specific context and user needs.
AD
Adelina 12 months ago
I think we practiced a question where we had to go back to business analysts for requirements. It might be worth pushing for updated performance expectations.
LO
Lorenza 12 months ago
I'm not entirely sure, but asking users for their expectations could help us gauge what they consider acceptable performance.
ED
Edmond 1 year ago
I remember we discussed using the legacy system's performance as a baseline in class. It seems like a logical starting point.
NI
Nieves 1 year ago
This is a great opportunity to show my problem-solving skills. I'll start by analyzing the legacy system, then engage the users to understand their expectations. With that information, I can propose reasonable performance targets.
JA
Jackie 1 year ago
I think the key here is to use a combination of approaches. Checking the legacy system performance, getting user feedback, and using industry benchmarks could all help me determine the right performance targets.
LA
Latanya 1 year ago
Hmm, I'm a bit confused on this one. I'm not sure if I should just ask the users or go back to the business analysts. Maybe a combination of both approaches would be best?
RO
Ronny 1 year ago
This is a tricky one. Without any performance requirements, I'm not sure how to determine the acceptable levels. I'll need to get creative and look at the legacy system as a starting point.
AD
Adaline 1 year ago
This seems like a straightforward question about using Salesforce features to create a supporters' score. I'll review the options and think about which one best fits the requirements.
SE
Selene 2 years ago
Hmm, I don't know, maybe we could just ask the magic 8-ball to determine the performance requirements? That seems as reliable as some of these other options.
MI
Ming 2 years ago
↳ replying to Selene
C) You should go back to the business analysts and require them to update the requirements to include the performance expectations
LA
Lashaunda 2 years ago
↳ replying to Selene
Hmm, that could be a good starting point to determine the acceptable performance levels.
MI
Mike 2 years ago
↳ replying to Selene
A) You should check the performance of the legacy system and use that as a benchmark for the new system
FR
Freeman 2 years ago
Option A is a good starting point, but the legacy system may have had its own performance issues that we don't want to carry forward. I'm with the majority on C and D as the best approach.
ST
Stevie 2 years ago
While B sounds tempting, users may not always have a realistic understanding of what's achievable. I'd lean towards a combination of C and D to get a solid, data-driven set of requirements.
EV
Eva 2 years ago
↳ replying to Stevie
D) You should use industry standard performance benchmarks
LE
Leana 2 years ago
↳ replying to Stevie
C) You should go back to the business analysts and require them to update the requirements to include the performance expectations
MA
Marguerita 2 years ago
↳ replying to Stevie
A) You should check the performance of the legacy system and use that as a benchmark for the new system
SH
Shantay 2 years ago
I think option C is the way to go. The business analysts should be responsible for defining the performance requirements upfront, not leaving it to the testing team to figure out.
VI
Viola 2 years ago
↳ replying to Shantay
That's a good point, using the legacy system's performance as a benchmark could also be helpful.
ER
Erasmo 2 years ago
↳ replying to Shantay
In that case, we could use industry standard benchmarks as a reference for acceptable performance levels.
NG
Ngoc 2 years ago
↳ replying to Shantay
But what if they don't have the expertise to define those requirements?
EL
Elina 2 years ago
↳ replying to Shantay
I agree, the business analysts should definitely update the requirements to include performance expectations.
OL
Olene 2 years ago
But shouldn't we also consider industry standard performance benchmarks to get a broader perspective?
BR
Breana 2 years ago
I agree with Reena. It's a good starting point to determine acceptable performance levels.
RE
Reena 2 years ago
I think we should check the performance of the legacy system as a benchmark.
0/2000 characters

Save Cancel