When unsealing Vault, each Shamir unseal key should be entered:
37 comments · newest first
SH
Shenika
11 months ago
Really? I didn't know you could do it that way!
DE
Delmy
11 months ago
I thought it had to be sequentially, like option A.
RE
Rebeca
11 months ago
Wait, why would you use PGP keys? That seems unnecessary.
WI
Wilson
12 months ago
Totally agree with B, that's the best practice!
HU
Huey
12 months ago
I think it's B, different admins on different systems.
CO
Colby
12 months ago
I don’t recall anything about using PGP keys for this process, so I’m not considering that option. It seems like it’s more about the unsealing method.
TE
Tegan
1 year ago
I’m a bit confused about whether the keys should be entered sequentially or from different systems. I feel like both could be valid in different contexts.
KA
Kaycee
1 year ago
I remember discussing the importance of having different admins input the keys to enhance security, so I’m leaning towards option B.
DA
Daren
1 year ago
I think we practiced something similar where we had to enter keys from different locations, but I'm not sure if it was specifically about Shamir's scheme.
NG
Nguyet
1 year ago
I've got it! The keys should be entered at the command line in a single command. That's the most efficient way to do it.
GA
Gary
1 year ago
I'm not sure about this one. I'll need to review the material again before deciding how to handle the Shamir unseal keys.
GI
Gilma
1 year ago
Wait, I'm a bit confused. Should the keys be entered by different admins from different computers instead?
TH
Thora
1 year ago
Okay, I think I know the answer to this. I'll enter the keys sequentially from one system that all the admins are in front of.
TE
Teresita
1 year ago
Hmm, this seems like a tricky one. I'll need to think carefully about the best approach here.
AN
Anna
1 year ago
Wait, we're not supposed to read the question out loud while doing a funny voice, are we? Darn, my plan is foiled.
CH
Chi
1 year ago
D) At the command line in one single command
EZ
Ezekiel
1 year ago
C) While encrypted with each administrators PGP key
SE
Selma
1 year ago
B) By different administrators each connecting from different computers
DA
Dannie
1 year ago
A) Sequentially from one system that all of the administrators are in front of
LO
Lorean
1 year ago
Encrypting the keys with PGP? That's overkill, don't you think? We're not launching nuclear missiles here.
VA
Val
1 year ago
Encrypting with PGP adds an extra layer of security, it's worth it in the long run.
GE
Gerri
1 year ago
I agree, we need to take all necessary precautions to protect sensitive information.
HA
Haley
1 year ago
It's better to be safe than sorry when it comes to security.
ST
Stephen
1 year ago
Entering the keys sequentially? Sounds like a recipe for disaster. What if one admin gets distracted and forgets their turn?
FR
Franchesca
1 year ago
Admin 3: We should consider using different administrators and computers for added security.
ME
Mertie
1 year ago
Admin 2: That sounds risky. What if someone forgets their turn?
SU
Susy
1 year ago
Admin 1: We should enter the keys sequentially to unseal the Vault.
ME
Merissa
2 years ago
Option D seems the most straightforward, but I'm not sure it's the most secure. Better to follow the best practices, even if it's a bit more work.
LI
Lindsay
1 year ago
It's always better to follow best practices when it comes to securing sensitive information like Vault unseal keys.
EL
Eleonore
1 year ago
Using PGP keys for encryption adds an extra layer of security to the unsealing process.
IS
Isaiah
1 year ago
I agree, it's important to have multiple administrators involved to prevent any single point of failure.
ST
Stefania
1 year ago
Option A seems like the safest choice to ensure all administrators are present and aware of the unsealing process.
ER
Erick
2 years ago
Hmm, I think option B is the way to go. It's important to have different admins involved to ensure proper separation of duties.
LI
Lizette
1 year ago
Option B is definitely the best choice for unsealing the Vault.
OD
Odelia
2 years ago
I think the keys should be encrypted with each administrators PGP key for added security.
TI
Tijuana
2 years ago
I disagree, I believe they should be entered by different administrators from different computers.
DA
Daisy
2 years ago
I think the Shamir unseal keys should be entered sequentially from one system.