Discuss CSI CSC2 Exam Topic 8 Question 7

What is the main pitfall of closet indexing for investors?

AThe portfolio does not closely resemble the benchmark index.

BInvestors must take greater risks due to a high portfolio beta.

Cpassively management fund can be marketed as actively managed.

DHigh portfolio turnover makes it unsuitable for taxable accounts

Suggested Answer: C

Closet indexing is a controversial practice where a fund manager claims to actively manage a portfolio but instead mirrors an index closely. This practice undermines the very premise of active management.

Main Pitfalls of Closet Indexing

Lack of Value Addition: Investors pay higher fees for active management without receiving the expected benefits, as the portfolio closely tracks a benchmark index.

Deceptive Marketing: Funds marketed as actively managed may mislead investors, violating transparency principles.

Limited Alpha Generation: Since the portfolio resembles an index, it often fails to deliver excess returns ('alpha'), defeating the purpose of active management.

Regulatory Concerns: Closet indexing raises ethical questions and can lead to scrutiny by regulatory bodies.

Why C is Correct

Option C highlights the core issue of closet indexing---misrepresenting a passively managed portfolio as active, leading to higher fees without the commensurate effort or performance.

Volume 2, Section 18: Mutual Funds---Indexing and Closet Indexing.

Volume 2, Section 13: Portfolio Manager Styles---Active vs. Passive Management.

Get Premium CSC2 Questions as Interactive Web-Based Practice Test or PDF Real Exam Format Detailed Explanations Instant Access Get Your Practice Test

30 comments · newest first

Larae 6 months ago

I lean towards A. Consistency with the index is key.

Jolene 6 months ago

C is misleading. It's not truly active management.

Justine 6 months ago

I agree, A makes sense. Misalignment is risky.

Loreen 7 months ago

D) is a big deal for me, high turnover is a killer!

Dong 7 months ago

B) sounds right, but isn't it all about the fees too?

Vincent 7 months ago

Surprised that people still think closet indexing is a good strategy!

Eden 8 months ago

I disagree, C) is the real problem here.

Gearldine 8 months ago

A) is definitely the main issue.

Dusti 8 months ago

Closet indexing is the financial equivalent of wearing sweatpants to the gym. You're just faking it, bro.

Earleen 8 months ago

A) is a valid point, but not the main pitfall. The portfolio not closely resembling the benchmark is a secondary issue.

Laurel 8 months ago

B) is not correct. Closet indexing actually reduces risk compared to active management.

Eladia 8 months ago

D) is the real pitfall. High portfolio turnover means higher taxes for investors in taxable accounts.

Ty 9 months ago

C) is the correct answer. Closet indexing allows fund managers to market their funds as actively managed when they are essentially just tracking the benchmark index.

Eliseo 9 months ago

I thought the main problem was how passively managed funds can be marketed as actively managed. That seems misleading, but I’m not 100% confident.

Truman 9 months ago

I recall a question about closet indexing where it mentioned the risks associated with a high portfolio beta. Could that be the answer?

Rasheeda 9 months ago

I'm not entirely sure, but I feel like the high portfolio turnover could be a big issue for taxable accounts. That sounds familiar from our study sessions.

Eve 9 months ago

Hmm, I'm not totally sure about this one. I'll need to review my notes on active vs. passive management to make the best guess here.

Josephine 9 months ago

I'm pretty confident I know the answer to this one. Closet indexing is when a fund is marketed as actively managed but actually just tracks the benchmark index. The main problem with that is it can mislead investors.

Simona 10 months ago

I think A is the main pitfall. It doesn't match the benchmark.

Diane 10 months ago

Okay, I've got a strategy here. I'll eliminate the options that don't seem directly related to the main issue with closet indexing, then focus on the remaining choices.

Renea 10 months ago

I think the main pitfall might be related to how closely the portfolio resembles the benchmark. I remember something about that in our practice questions.

Roselle 10 months ago

D is important. High turnover can hurt taxes.

Annmarie 10 months ago

B could be an issue too. Higher beta means more risk.

Roslyn 11 months ago

I'm a bit confused by the question. Can someone clarify what exactly "closet indexing" refers to? I want to make sure I understand the concept before attempting to answer.

Shawn 11 months ago

Hmm, this seems like a tricky one. I'll need to think carefully about the pros and cons of closet indexing to determine the main pitfall.

Alberto 5 months ago

↳ replying to Shawn

True, but I still lean towards A. It’s all about alignment with the index.

Rikki 5 months ago

↳ replying to Shawn

C is interesting. Misleading marketing can confuse investors.

Veta 6 months ago

↳ replying to Shawn

What about B? Greater risks could be a serious pitfall too.

Jesus 6 months ago

↳ replying to Shawn

I agree, but D also makes sense. High turnover can hurt taxable accounts.

Edwin 6 months ago

↳ replying to Shawn

I think it's A. The portfolio not resembling the benchmark is a big issue.

CSI CSC2 Exam - Topic 8 Question 7 Discussion