Deal of The Day! Hurry Up, Grab the Special Discount - Save 25% - Ends In 00:00:00 Coupon code: SAVE25
Welcome to Pass4Success

- Free Preparation Discussions

AICPA CPA-Financial Exam - Topic 2 Question 125 Discussion

Posted by Hollis on May 02, 2026 at 03:55 AM

On December 31, 20X2, the Board of Directors of Maxy Manufacturing, Inc. committed to a plan to discontinue the operations of its Alpha division. Maxy estimated that Alpha's 20X3 operating loss would be $500,000 and that the fair value of Alpha's facilities was $300,000 less than their carrying amounts.

Alpha's 20X2 operating loss was $1,400,000, and the division was actually sold for $400,000 less than its carrying amount in 20X3. Maxy's effective tax rate is 30%.

In its 20X2 income statement, what amount should Maxy report as loss from discontinued operations?

Suggested Answer: B

Choice 'b' is correct. Since the fair value of Alpha's facilities was $300,000 less than its carrying value, there has been an impairment loss, and that loss should be recognized in 20X2. That $300,000 impairment loss plus the $1,400,000 20X2 operating loss would be recognized in 20X2 net of tax. The total loss would be $1,700,000 70% (100% - 30%) or $1,190,000.

Choice 'a' is incorrect. It includes the 20X2 operating loss of $1,400,000 but not the $300,000 impairment loss but does report the 20X2 operating loss net of tax.

Choice 'c' is incorrect. It includes the 20X2 operating loss of $1,400,000, but not the $300,000 impairment loss, and reports the 20X2 operating loss gross of tax and not net of tax.

Choice 'd' is incorrect. It reports the 20X2 loss from discontinued operations gross of tax and not net of tax.


Get Premium CPA-Financial Questions as Interactive Web-Based Practice Test or PDF Real Exam Format Detailed Explanations Instant Access Get Your Practice Test
24 comments · newest first
MY
My 2 days ago
I’m leaning towards D) $1,700,000. The total loss seems higher.
LE
Lenna 7 days ago
Right, but the operating loss already accounts for some of that.
SH
Shelia 12 days ago
True, but we need to consider the total loss including the fair value drop.
LE
Lenna 17 days ago
I feel like it’s A) $980,000. The tax effect is important.
SH
Shelia 22 days ago
This question is tricky. I think it's B) $1,190,000.
SH
Sheron 28 days ago
Exactly! It’s crucial for the final amount reported.
AL
Alyce 1 month ago
So, we’re all thinking about the tax effect then?
JO
Josephine 1 month ago
Yes, it does! That’s why B seems reasonable.
GE
German 1 month ago
I’m confused about the tax impact. Does it apply to all losses?
RI
Rikki 2 months ago
Right! So, we should factor in all losses for a complete picture.
TA
Tatum 2 months ago
I believe the total loss should reflect the sale loss too.
SH
Sheron 2 months ago
I’m leaning towards A. The losses add up differently.
AL
Alyce 2 months ago
I feel like option B could be right. It includes the tax effect.
HU
Huey 2 months ago
Definitely! We need to consider both operating losses and the fair value drop.
JO
Josephine 2 months ago
This question is tricky. I think it's about calculating the total loss.
MA
Mariko 3 months ago
Isn't $1,700,000 a bit high for the total loss?
RO
Rosendo 3 months ago
Wait, how can they report a loss if they sold it for less?
PE
Peter 3 months ago
Definitely going with option B, that makes sense.
CO
Cornell 3 months ago
I think the total loss should include the prior year's loss too.
AN
Andra 3 months ago
The estimated loss for 20X3 is $500,000.
LO
Lonna 4 months ago
I'm confused about whether to include the tax effect on the total loss or just report the gross amounts. I hope I remember the right approach!
JO
Josue 5 months ago
I practiced a similar question where we had to account for both the operating loss and the loss on sale, so I think we might need to add those together here.
LO
Lorenza 5 months ago
I remember something about adding the estimated operating loss for 20X3 to the 20X2 loss, but I can't recall if we also factor in the fair value adjustments.
WI
Wilford 5 months ago
I think the loss from discontinued operations should include the operating loss and any losses on the sale, but I'm not sure how to calculate it correctly.
0/2000 characters

Save Cancel