Deal of The Day! Hurry Up, Grab the Special Discount - Save 25% - Ends In 00:00:00 Coupon code: SAVE25
Welcome to Pass4Success

- Free Preparation Discussions

Qlik QSDA2024 Exam - Topic 3 Question 9 Discussion

Posted by Franchesca on Sep 16, 2024 at 07:46 PM

Exhibit.

Refer to the exhibit.

A data architect is working on a Qlik Sense app the business has created to analyze the company orders and shipments.

To understand the table structure, the business has given the following summary:

* Every order creates a unique orderlD and an order date in the Orders table

* An order can contain one or more order lines one for each product ID in the order details table

* Products In the order are shipped (shipment date) as soon as they are ready and can be shipped separately

* The dates need to be analyzed separately by Year, Month, and Quarter

The data architect realizes the data model has issues that must be fixed. Which steps should the data architect perform?

Suggested Answer: C

In the given data model, there are several issues related to table relationships and key fields that need to be addressed to create a functional and optimized data model. Here's how each step in the chosen solution (Option C) resolves these issues:

Create a key with OrderID and ProductID in the OrderDetails table and in the Shipments table:

By creating a composite key with OrderID and ProductID, you uniquely identify each line item in both the OrderDetails and Shipments tables. This step is crucial for ensuring that each product within an order is correctly associated with its respective shipment.

Delete the ShipmentID in the Orders table:

The ShipmentID in the Orders table is redundant because the Shipments table already captures this information at a more granular level (i.e., at the product level). Removing ShipmentID avoids potential circular references or synthetic keys.

Delete the ProductID and OrderID in the Shipments table:

After creating the composite key in step 1, the individual ProductID and OrderID fields in the Shipments table are no longer necessary for joins. Removing them reduces redundancy and simplifies the table structure.

Concatenate Orders and OrderDetails:

Concatenating Orders and OrderDetails into a single table creates a unified table that contains all necessary order-related information. This helps in simplifying the model and avoiding issues related to managing separate but related tables.

Create a link table using the MasterCalendar table and create a concatenated field between OrderDate and ShipmentDate:

A link table is created to associate the combined table with the MasterCalendar. By creating a concatenated field that combines OrderDate and ShipmentDate, you ensure that both dates are properly linked to the calendar, allowing for accurate time-based analysis.


Get Premium QSDA2024 Questions as Interactive Web-Based Practice Test or PDF Real Exam Format Detailed Explanations Instant Access Get Your Practice Test
38 comments · newest first
RE
Regenia 11 months ago
Not sure about deleting ProductID in the Shipments table, seems risky.
AL
Alaine 11 months ago
Definitely need to create those keys in the OrderDetails table!
CE
Cecilia 11 months ago
Surprised there are so many steps involved! Thought it would be simpler.
HA
Han 11 months ago
I disagree, B seems more straightforward with the concatenation.
AN
Anjelica 11 months ago
Looks like option A is the best choice for fixing the data model.
TI
Timothy 12 months ago
I recall that using the MasterCalendar table is crucial for date analysis, but I can't remember if we should derive fields or concatenate them.
LO
Louis 12 months ago
I feel like I might be mixing up the steps for deleting IDs in the tables. Shouldn't we be careful about which IDs we remove?
RI
Rikki 12 months ago
I think option B sounds familiar because it mentions creating a link table, which we practiced in a similar question.
SA
Samira 1 year ago
I remember we discussed the importance of creating keys for proper joins, but I'm not sure if it's better to concatenate or left join in this case.
GI
Gilbert 1 year ago
I feel pretty confident about this question. The steps seem straightforward, and I've worked with similar data structures before. I'll just need to double-check my work to make sure I haven't overlooked anything.
LA
Lavina 1 year ago
This is a good opportunity to demonstrate my data modeling skills. I'll need to be thorough in my approach and make sure I don't miss any important details.
LI
Linwood 1 year ago
Okay, I think I've got a good handle on this. The key is creating the right relationships between the tables and using the MasterCalendar table to get the date analysis we need.
HE
Helga 1 year ago
Hmm, I'm a bit confused by the different table structures mentioned. I'll need to make sure I understand the relationships between the tables before I start making changes.
VA
Valda 1 year ago
This looks like a tricky data modeling question. I'll need to carefully read through the requirements and think through the steps to get the data structure right.
AR
Armanda 2 years ago
I bet the data architect is wishing they had a magic 'Fix-It' button right about now. Gotta love those complex data models!
LO
Lou 2 years ago
↳ replying to Armanda
Yeah, having a 'Fix-It' button would definitely make things easier for the data architect.
LO
Lou 2 years ago
↳ replying to Armanda
I think the data architect should carefully follow the steps provided to fix the issues.
LO
Lou 2 years ago
↳ replying to Armanda
I know, data modeling can be a real headache sometimes.
VA
Val 2 years ago
Wait, did they just suggest deleting the ShipmentID in the Orders table? That's like cutting off your arm to fix a papercut!
FL
Flo 2 years ago
I like the idea of using a Derive statement with the MasterCalendar table to apply the fields to OrderDate and ShipmentDate. It's a clever way to handle the date analysis.
LO
Louvenia 2 years ago
↳ replying to Flo
A: Definitely, having a clear structure for the data and utilizing the MasterCalendar table for date analysis will improve the overall data model.
SI
Simona 2 years ago
↳ replying to Flo
B: I agree, option A seems to address the issues in the data model effectively. It's important to handle the dates separately for analysis.
FA
Fabiola 2 years ago
↳ replying to Flo
A: I think option A is the way to go. It suggests creating a key with OrderID and ProductID, deleting unnecessary fields, and using Derive statement for date analysis.
AB
Abel 2 years ago
Concatenating Orders and OrderDetails, and creating a link table using the MasterCalendar table is a great way to analyze the dates by year, month, and quarter.
RO
Rodolfo 2 years ago
↳ replying to Abel
B) 5. Create a link table using the MasterCalendar table and create a concatenated field between OrderDate and ShipmentDate
JU
Justine 2 years ago
↳ replying to Abel
B) 4. Concatenate Orders and OrderDetails
CA
Candra 2 years ago
↳ replying to Abel
B) 3. Delete the ProductID and OrderID in the OrderDetails table
LI
Lilli 2 years ago
↳ replying to Abel
B) 2. Delete the ShipmentID in the Shipments table
CA
Carline 2 years ago
↳ replying to Abel
B) 1. Create a key with OrderID and ProductID in the OrderDetails table and in the Orders table
AR
Arminda 2 years ago
I'm not sure about the derive statement with the MasterCalendar table. Maybe using a left join between Orders and OrderDetails would be better for analyzing the dates separately.
GL
Gladys 2 years ago
Deleting the ShipmentID from the Shipments table and the ProductID and OrderID from the OrderDetails table is crucial to simplify the data structure.
YA
Yaeko 2 years ago
I agree with Ona. Deleting the ShipmentID in the Shipments table and creating a link table with the MasterCalendar seems like the right steps to fix the data model.
NI
Nieves 2 years ago
The key with OrderID and ProductID in the OrderDetails and Orders tables seems like a logical step to fix the data model.
AL
Albert 2 years ago
↳ replying to Nieves
A) 4. Left join Orders and OrderDetails
KA
Karima 2 years ago
↳ replying to Nieves
A) 3. Delete the ProductID and OrderID in the Shipments table
EL
Elouise 2 years ago
↳ replying to Nieves
A) 2. Delete the ShipmentID in the Orders table
AU
Audrie 2 years ago
↳ replying to Nieves
A) 1. Create a key with OrderID and ProductID in the OrderDetails table and in the Orders table
ON
Ona 2 years ago
I think the data architect should create a key with OrderID and ProductID in the OrderDetails table and Orders table.
0/2000 characters

Save Cancel