A large public library established an EMS in accordance with ISO 14001 requirements, which was third-party certified 10 years ago. You are performing the second surveillance audit of the third certification cycle. The audit plan included an audit of the Director as the last interview before the closing meeting.
During the interview with the Director, you audit clause 6.2 (Objectives and planning to achieve them). The dialogue is as follows:
You: Could you please tell me which environmental objectives were defined for last year and show evidence of their achievement?
Director: Yes. We had defined three objectives. As you can see from our Annual Plan, one of them was to separate our waste into four categories: paper, plastics, metals, and food. Before, we had only three (plastic and paper were disposed of together). The deadline is in six months. We developed an Action Plan to achieve this objective.
Which six of the questions would you ask related to this objective?
In accordance with ISO 14001:2015 Clause 6.2.1 (Environmental objectives) and Clause 6.2.2 (Planning actions to achieve environmental objectives), the standard sets explicit criteria for establishing objectives and determining how to achieve them.
To audit compliance against Clause 6.2 in this scenario, an auditor must evaluate six key criteria explicitly required by the standard:
What resources did you need? (Option B / Clause 6.2.2 b): Determines whether necessary resources (e.g., bins, signage, contractor services) were allocated.
Did you communicate it to relevant personnel? (Option D / Clause 6.2.1 f & Clause 7.4): Evaluates if objectives were effectively communicated across relevant functions and levels.
Is it consistent with the environmental policy? (Option E / Clause 6.2.1 a): Verifies alignment with top management commitments to pollution prevention and compliance.
Did you keep any documented information? (Option F / Clause 6.2.1): Confirms the mandatory requirement to maintain documented information on environmental objectives.
How is it being monitored? (Option I / Clause 6.2.1 e & Clause 6.2.2 e): Audits how progress is evaluated, including indicators and integration into business processes.
Is it measurable? (Option J / Clause 6.2.1 b): Checks whether the objective is measurable (if practicable) or capable of performance evaluation.
Questions regarding formal Director approval, specific manager designation, hypothetical deadline failure consequences, or update schedules are administrative considerations not directly dictated as core clause requirements.
Which two audit characteristics are features of a Stage 1 initial certification audit?
According to ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 Clause 9.3.2.1:
Stage 1 includes:
Reviewing management system documentation (E).
Identifying areas of concern that could become nonconformities at Stage 2 (C).
Evaluating readiness for Stage 2, but not making certification decisions (D).
Stage 1 focuses on preparedness; Stage 2 evaluates full implementation (F).
Onsite requirement (B) is generally true but flexibility is permitted per IAF MD rules.
=============================
You are conducting a Stage 2 certification audit of VitalSpark, a pharmaceutical organisation manufacturing vitamins and other healthcare medicines. In a separate area in the centre of their large site, a supplier produces oxygen supplies piped directly into the manufacturing processes of VitalSpark. They also deliver oxygen in bulk tankers to other customers. When you review the environmental aspects register, you find that the only environmental aspect recorded for this arrangement relates to the heavy goods vehicles of the supplier transiting the site.
You ask the EMS Manager about the environmental consequences to VitalSpark of this arrangement and are told that they are not significant since the supplier has its own services for water, sewage, waste and energy. The EMS Manager tried unsuccessfully to communicate with the supplier who is located inside the VitalSpark site and outside the scope of the EMS.
You raise a non-conformance against clause 6.1.2 of ISO 14001:
"VitalSpark does not maintain documented information on aspects/impacts related to activities, products and services of the oxygen supplier."
Which combination of two of the following actions proposed by VitalSpark would permit you to close out the nonconformity?
An audit team leader arrives at a steel fabrication organisation that manufactures fire escape stairs to carry out a Stage 2 certification audit. At a meeting with the EMS Manager, she is informed that they have secured their largest contract from a construction organisation to manufacture and install fire escape stairs. They appointed a subcontractor to perform the installation work. The EMS Manager wants the ISO 14001 audit extended to cover the installation site.
During the audit, a team member found that several complaints had been made to the organisation regarding their installation operators being seen to dispose of excess paint into the site drains, which breached legal requirements. The EMS Manager blames the contractors they had to take on because of the big contract. The auditor raises a nonconformance against clause 8.1 of ISO 14001.
Which one of the following statements would support this finding?
The correct answer is A.
This finding relates to ISO 14001:2015 Clause 8.1 --- Operational planning and control. Clause 8.1 requires the organisation to control or influence outsourced processes and to communicate relevant environmental requirements to external providers, including contractors.
In this case, the installation work was subcontracted, but the environmental impact still occurred as part of the organisation's activities and contracted work. The disposal of excess paint into site drains created a legal breach and showed that the organisation had not effectively controlled or influenced the outsourced installation activity.
A is correct because a contract is a key way to communicate operational controls and environmental requirements to a subcontractor. If the installation contract did not require the subcontractor to comply with the organisation's EMS policy or environmental requirements, this supports a nonconformity against Clause 8.1.
The other options are linked to different ISO 14001 clauses:
B relates more closely to Clause 7.3 --- Awareness. C relates more closely to Clause 7.1 --- Resources. D relates more closely to Clause 7.2 --- Competence.
Therefore, the statement that best supports a nonconformity against ISO 14001 Clause 8.1 is A.
During a Stage 1 audit, the EMS Manager asks that the audit includes coverage of a new storage site on the other side of town that they have taken over since the application was made.
Which two of the following actions should the auditor take?
Maria Jones
2 months agoHarold Nguyen
2 months agoEric Scott
3 months agoTimothy Lewis
3 months agoDeborah Flores
4 months agoMargaret Bailey
4 months agoEmma Morris
5 months agoRachel King
5 months agoDaniel Campbell
6 months agoPatricia Lewis
6 months agoFrank Jackson
7 months agoDennis Hall
6 months agoGerald Baker
6 months agoMargaret Carter
6 months agoNathan Phillips
6 months agoEmily Garcia
6 months agoAnisha
7 months agoRhea
7 months agoLynsey
8 months agoLevi
8 months agoKasandra
8 months agoMalcolm
8 months agoKati
9 months agoEnola
9 months agoAudria
9 months agoRichelle
9 months agoClorinda
10 months agoShenika
10 months agoYvonne
10 months agoIndia
10 months agoBulah
11 months agoOdette
11 months agoValentine
11 months agoOcie
11 months agoVirgina
12 months agoJunita
12 months agoKing
1 year agoArthur
1 year agoHannah
1 year agoQuiana
1 year agoLudivina
1 year agoVeronique
1 year agoTresa
1 year agoCassandra
1 year agoChristene
1 year agoAlverta
1 year agoWillard
1 year agoKatheryn
1 year agoAbel
1 year agoElza
1 year agoTamar
1 year agoShantell
1 year agoStephanie
1 year ago