MENU
Buy-sell agreement may specify that the shares be valued strictly at their fair market value as:
Suggested Answer: C
Get Premium CVA Questions
as Interactive Web-Based Practice Test or PDF
Real Exam Format
Detailed Explanations
Instant Access
Get Your Practice Test
35 comments · newest first
BE
Beckie
11 months ago
I thought controlling interests were always valued higher?
LO
Loreen
11 months ago
Definitely B, no discounts should apply!
JA
Janessa
11 months ago
Wait, can you really discount for lack of control? Seems unfair.
DE
Detra
12 months ago
I think option D makes the most sense here.
CH
Chau
12 months ago
Fair market value is key in buy-sell agreements!
LE
Lemuel
1 year ago
I’m leaning towards D because it seems like both B and C could apply in different scenarios we studied.
NA
Nan
1 year ago
I feel like I’ve seen questions that mention discounts before, so maybe C could be correct too?
SA
Samira
1 year ago
I think option B sounds familiar because we practiced valuing shares without discounts for control or marketability.
WI
Wilbert
1 year ago
I remember discussing fair market value in class, but I'm not sure if it always means controlling interests.
RE
Refugia
1 year ago
B looks like the best answer to me. The question is specifically asking about how the shares should be valued, and B describes the valuation approach without any discounts, which seems most appropriate.
AN
Anthony
1 year ago
Okay, let me break this down step-by-step. The key is understanding the difference between fair market value, controlling ownership interests, and discounts for lack of control or marketability. I'll work through each answer choice methodically.
MI
Miesha
1 year ago
Hmm, I'm a bit unsure about this one. I'll need to think through the different options carefully to make sure I understand the nuances between them.
AL
Alica
1 year ago
This question seems straightforward, I think the answer is B based on the description of proportionate share of enterprise value with no discounts.
CL
Clay
1 year ago
The exam gods are really testing our understanding of business valuation here. Option B sounds like the 'fair' choice, but option C might be more realistic in the real world.
ST
Stanton
1 year ago
Yeah, option B sounds good in theory, but option C might be the way to go in real-world scenarios.
DA
Daren
1 year ago
I agree, option B is ideal but option C might be more common in actual buy-sell agreements.
OL
Oliva
1 year ago
It's true, option B seems fair but option C could be more realistic in practice.
NA
Nadine
1 year ago
I think option B makes sense in theory, but option C might be more practical.
CH
Chaya
1 year ago
As an accountant, I'd say option C is the way to go. A specified percentage discount is a more practical approach than trying to determine a 'fair' value.
LA
Larue
1 year ago
Haha, I guess the shareholders are trying to have their cake and eat it too with option D. Can't decide on fair market value or a discount? Why not both!
CI
Ciara
1 year ago
Glenn: Exactly, can't decide on fair market value or a discount, so why not have both?
GL
Glenn
1 year ago
User 2: I agree, it's like having their cake and eating it too.
ST
Stanford
1 year ago
User 1: Yeah, option D seems like they want the best of both worlds.
IS
Isaac
1 year ago
I'm torn between B and D. The absence of discounts for lack of control or marketability makes sense, but a specified percentage discount could also be reasonable.
RE
Remedios
1 year ago
That's true. D does cover all possibilities. It might be the safer choice.
BA
Barney
1 year ago
I see your point, but D could also work. It includes both options, so it covers all bases.
FL
Flo
1 year ago
I think B makes more sense. No discounts for lack of control or marketability.
LI
Lilli
2 years ago
Option B seems like the most logical choice, as it specifies the shares should be valued at a proportionate share of the enterprise value without any discounts.
HA
Harris
1 year ago
I think it ultimately depends on the specific circumstances of the agreement.
TA
Tawna
1 year ago
True, having both options B and C covered could provide more flexibility.
MA
Marilynn
1 year ago
But option D also includes option B, so it might be a better choice.
WA
Wayne
2 years ago
I agree, option B does seem like the most logical choice.
MA
Marnie
2 years ago
I'm not sure about that, I think it could also be C) At a specified percentage discount from a proportionate share of total enterprise value.
ON
Onita
2 years ago
I agree with Roosevelt, because it makes sense to value the shares at a proportionate share of the enterprise value with no discounts.
RO
Roosevelt
2 years ago
I think the answer is D) Both B & C.