Deal of The Day! Hurry Up, Grab the Special Discount - Save 25% - Ends In 00:00:00 Coupon code: SAVE25
Welcome to Pass4Success

- Free Preparation Discussions

ISTQB CTFL-Foundation Exam - Topic 3 Question 22 Discussion

Posted by Renay on Sep 08, 2024 at 06:42 PM

Refer to the exhibit.

The decision table above shows a company's fuel expenses structure.

Which of the following Test Cases based on the decision table are Valid?

Test Case 1:

An employee who is not a car or motorcycle driver attempts to claim fuel expenses. Expected result: Expense claim not allowed.

Test Case 2:

An employee who drives a 1700cc diesel car attempts to claim fuel expenses. Expected result: Expense claim accepted at band C.

Test Case 3:

An employee who rides a motorcycle attempts to claim fuel expenses. Expected result: Expense claim accepted at band A.

Suggested Answer: D

Get Premium CTFL-Foundation Questions as Interactive Web-Based Practice Test or PDF Real Exam Format Detailed Explanations Instant Access Get Your Practice Test
35 comments · newest first
JI
Jillian 10 months ago
Test Case 2 being valid seems off, isn’t 1700cc too high for band C?
HU
Hubert 11 months ago
Totally agree, Test Cases 1 and 3 make sense to me!
GL
Glen 11 months ago
Wait, how can Test Case 3 be valid? Motorcycles usually get less!
VI
Virgina 11 months ago
I think Test Case 2 is valid, diesel cars should be accepted!
HE
Heike 11 months ago
Test Case 1 is definitely valid, no claim for non-drivers.
GL
Gladys 12 months ago
I feel like Test Case 2 is valid, but I might be mixing it up with a similar question we practiced.
MA
Mary 12 months ago
Test Case 3 seems right to me; motorcycles usually fall under a lower expense band, so that should be valid.
TI
Timothy 12 months ago
I'm not entirely sure about Test Case 2. I thought diesel cars were in a different band, but I can't recall the specifics.
TA
Taryn 1 year ago
I remember we discussed decision tables in class, and I think Test Case 1 should be valid since non-drivers shouldn't get claims.
AN
Anglea 1 year ago
Confident I can solve this. The key is to carefully compare each test case to the decision table and determine if the expected result matches the criteria.
EL
Eleonore 1 year ago
I think I've got it! Test Cases 1 and 3 are valid, but Test Case 2 is invalid because the car engine size is not within the range specified in the table.
IL
Iluminada 1 year ago
I'm a bit confused by the wording of the test cases. I'll need to read through them a few times to make sure I understand what's being tested.
SI
Silvana 1 year ago
Okay, let's see. The decision table shows the fuel expense structure, so I need to check if each test case matches the criteria in the table.
JA
Janna 1 year ago
Hmm, this looks like a tricky one. I'll need to carefully analyze the decision table and the test cases to determine which ones are valid.
ME
Melda 1 year ago
I think the answer is C. The question specifically mentions the user is locked out, so the best option is to go to the User Manager and reset their password to unlock the account.
CH
Chau 1 year ago
I'm just glad I don't have to commute by horse. That would be a whole different expense claim scenario!
GL
Glendora 1 year ago
Test Case 2 is invalid because the decision table clearly states that a 1700cc diesel car should be in band C, not accepted at band C. The other two test cases are valid.
JO
Joaquin 1 year ago
↳ replying to Glendora
Yes, Test Case 2 is definitely incorrect based on the decision table. Test Cases 1 and 3 follow the rules accurately.
CA
Carmen 1 year ago
↳ replying to Glendora
I agree, Test Case 2 does not match the decision table criteria. Test Cases 1 and 3 seem to align correctly.
RE
Renato 1 year ago
↳ replying to Glendora
Test Case 2 is invalid because the decision table clearly states that a 1700cc diesel car should be in band C, not accepted at band C. The other two test cases are valid.
BR
Britt 1 year ago
Hmm, the decision table seems a bit confusing. I hope the real exam won't be this tricky!
FR
France 1 year ago
↳ replying to Britt
User 3: Test Case 2 looks valid to me, based on the information provided.
BR
Brett 1 year ago
↳ replying to Britt
User 2: I agree, Test Case 1 doesn't seem to match the criteria in the decision table.
JO
Joni 1 year ago
↳ replying to Britt
User 1: I think Test Case 1 is invalid, but Test Case 3 is valid.
JI
Jina 1 year ago
All three test cases are valid as they cover the different scenarios mentioned in the decision table.
DE
Derick 1 year ago
↳ replying to Jina
Yes, Test Cases 1, 2, and 3 are all valid.
EL
Elenore 1 year ago
↳ replying to Jina
So, the correct answer is option C.
MY
Myrtie 1 year ago
↳ replying to Jina
I agree, they cover all the scenarios in the decision table.
JE
Jerrod 1 year ago
↳ replying to Jina
I think all three test cases are valid.
AR
Arlette 1 year ago
Test Cases 1 and 3 are valid as they follow the decision table. However, Test Case 2 is invalid as the decision table shows that a 1700cc diesel car should be in band C, not accepted at band C.
JE
Jesusa 1 year ago
↳ replying to Arlette
I agree, the decision table clearly shows that a 1700cc diesel car should be in band C.
BO
Bonita 1 year ago
↳ replying to Arlette
I think Test Cases 1 and 3 are valid, but Test Case 2 is invalid.
TA
Tammara 1 year ago
So, we both think that option B is the correct answer, right?
NI
Nieves 1 year ago
I agree with you, Tammara. Test Case 2 should be valid because a 1700cc diesel car falls under band C.
TA
Tammara 2 years ago
I think Test Case 1 is invalid because the expense claim should not be allowed for non-car or motorcycle drivers.
0/2000 characters

Save Cancel