Discuss ISQI CTFL-AcT Exam Topic 1 Question 9

Which of the following is the BEST example of a Gherkin-style test for a web-based banking application?

AGIVEN I have $5000 on my personal account X AND I have $200 on my personal account Y
WHEN I transfer $1000 from X to Y
THEN I should have balance $4000 on my personal account X AND I should have balance $1200 on my personal account Y

BGIVEN I have $5000 on my personal account X AND I have $200 on my personal account Y
WHEN I click 'Make transfer' button AND I enter '3000' into 'Amount' field
AND I enter 'X' into 'From which account' field AND I enter 'Y' into 'To which account' field AND I click 'Confirm transaction' button
THEN I should have balance $2000 on my personal account X AND I should have balance $3200 on my personal account Y

CGIVEN I have $5000 on my personal account X and $600 on my personal account Y WHEN I transfer $500 from Y to X
THEN I should have balance $4500 on X and balance $1100 on Y

DGIVEN I have $5000 on my personal account X WHEN I have $600 on my personal account Y
THEN I have $5600 in total on my personal accounts X and Y

Suggested Answer: A

Get Premium CTFL-AcT Questions as Interactive Web-Based Practice Test or PDF Real Exam Format Detailed Explanations Instant Access Get Your Practice Test

12 comments · newest first

Gregoria 12 months ago

Wait, can you really transfer more than you have? Sounds fishy!

Myrtie 12 months ago

D is too vague, doesn't show the transfer process.

Rima 12 months ago

C seems off, the math doesn't add up.

Franklyn 1 year ago

I think B is better since it includes the UI actions.

Jame 1 year ago

Option A is super clear and straightforward.

Noel 1 year ago

I thought option C was a good example too, but it seems to mix up the accounts a bit. I guess I need to review the format again.

Kattie 1 year ago

I practiced a similar question, and I feel like option B is too detailed with all the button clicks. Gherkin should be more high-level, right?

Lashaun 1 year ago

I'm not entirely sure, but I remember that Gherkin should be clear and concise. Maybe option D fits that better?

Rosalind 1 year ago

I think Gherkin tests should focus on behavior rather than implementation details, so I'm leaning towards option A.

Lai 1 year ago

I'm a little confused by the wording of the options. What's the difference between a "master-detail relationship field" and a "lookup relationship field"? I'll need to review those relationship types to make sure I understand them before selecting an answer.

Mitsue 1 year ago

It feels like service governance is involved in this process, so I might go with option C.

Gerri 1 year ago

I remember practicing a similar question where we discussed how MRP determines what to produce and when, which might suggest it's about shop orders and purchases.

iSQI CTFL-AcT Exam - Topic 1 Question 9 Discussion