Deal of The Day! Hurry Up, Grab the Special Discount - Save 25% - Ends In 00:00:00 Coupon code: SAVE25
Welcome to Pass4Success

- Free Preparation Discussions

Isaca CISA Exam - Topic 2 Question 94 Discussion

Posted by Maynard on Jan 15, 2025 at 12:15 AM

Which of the following would provide the BEST evidence that a cloud provider's change management process is effective?

Suggested Answer: C

The results of a third-party review provided by the vendor would provide the best evidence that a cloud provider's change management process is effective, because it would be an independent and objective assessment of the vendor's compliance with best practices and standards for managing changes in the cloud environment. A third-party review would also include testing of the vendor's change management controls and procedures, and provide recommendations for improvement if needed.

Minutes from regular change management meetings with the vendor would not provide sufficient evidence, because they would only reflect the vendor's self-reported information and may not capture all the changes that occurred or their impact on the cloud services. Written assurances from the vendor's CEO and CIO would also not provide sufficient evidence, because they would be based on the vendor's own opinion and may not be verified by external sources. A copy of change management policies provided by the vendor would not provide sufficient evidence, because it would only show the vendor's intended approach to change management, but not how it is implemented or monitored in practice.


ISACA Cloud Computing Audit Program, Section 4.5: Change Management

Cloud Computing: Business Benefits With Security, Governance and Assurance Perspectives, Section 4.3: Change Management

Get Premium CISA Questions as Interactive Web-Based Practice Test or PDF Real Exam Format Detailed Explanations Instant Access Get Your Practice Test
30 comments · newest first
LI
Linn 10 months ago
Policies are good, but they need to be enforced!
LA
Lashaunda 11 months ago
Wait, can we really trust the vendor's own review?
LI
Linwood 11 months ago
Written assurances? Sounds like fluff to me.
JO
Joanna 11 months ago
I think third-party reviews are more reliable.
DI
Dianne 11 months ago
Minutes from meetings show actual discussions happening.
BR
Brandon 12 months ago
I lean towards option D because having documented policies is important, but I wonder if they really prove effectiveness without seeing them in action.
EZ
Ezekiel 12 months ago
I feel like minutes from meetings (option A) could show ongoing discussions, but they might not reflect actual effectiveness.
LA
Lavera 12 months ago
I'm not so sure about that. I remember a practice question where internal documents were considered less reliable than external audits.
CH
Chantell 1 year ago
I think option C might be the best choice since a third-party review would provide an unbiased perspective on the change management process.
AF
Afton 1 year ago
I'm leaning towards the third-party review as well. That seems like the most objective and thorough way to assess the effectiveness of their change management process. The other options feel a bit too subjective or limited in scope.
IR
Irving 1 year ago
I think the key here is to look for independent verification of the cloud provider's change management practices, rather than just taking their word for it. The third-party review seems like the most reliable option to me.
MI
Misty 1 year ago
Hmm, I'm a bit unsure about this one. I'm trying to think through what kind of evidence would best demonstrate the effectiveness of their change management process. The third-party review might be a good option, but I'm not totally sure.
WE
Wendell 1 year ago
This seems like a pretty straightforward question. I'd focus on looking for objective evidence of the cloud provider's change management process, rather than just relying on their assurances.
LY
Lynelle 2 years ago
I think C) The results of a third-party review provided by the vendor could also be strong evidence of effective change management.
MA
Magda 2 years ago
I agree with Whitley. Having documented minutes from meetings shows ongoing communication and oversight.
WH
Whitley 2 years ago
I think A) Minutes from regular change management meetings with the vendor would be the best evidence.
JO
Jolanda 2 years ago
The third-party review is the clear winner here. Unless the vendor's CEO and CIO are also world-class magicians, in which case I might consider their written assurances.
JO
Joaquin 2 years ago
A copy of the change management policies? Might as well ask the vendor to recite the policies while juggling chainsaws. The third-party review is the way to go, folks.
MA
Madalyn 2 years ago
↳ replying to Joaquin
I agree, a third-party review is more reliable than just trusting what the vendor says.
JA
Jade 2 years ago
↳ replying to Joaquin
Vendor's CEO and CIO could just be giving lip service, we need independent verification.
JA
Javier 2 years ago
Vendor's CEO and CIO assurances? More like hot air and empty promises. I'll take the third-party review any day!
JA
Janella 2 years ago
↳ replying to Javier
A copy of the change management policies could also give insight into how the process is structured.
HA
Harley 2 years ago
↳ replying to Javier
I think minutes from change management meetings would also be helpful to see the process in action.
CA
Carmen 2 years ago
↳ replying to Javier
I agree, third-party reviews are more reliable than promises from the CEO and CIO.
WI
Willow 2 years ago
The change management meeting minutes could be a good indicator, but I'm not sure they'd provide the full picture. The third-party review seems like the safest bet.
DA
Darell 2 years ago
I think the third-party review would give the best evidence of the change management process. The vendor's own policies and assurances might not be as objective.
LE
Lewis 2 years ago
↳ replying to Darell
D) A copy of change management policies provided by the vendor
SH
Sharee 2 years ago
↳ replying to Darell
I agree, a third-party review would be more objective.
OL
Olga 2 years ago
↳ replying to Darell
C) The results of a third-party review provided by the vendor
SH
Sherman 2 years ago
↳ replying to Darell
A) Minutes from regular change management meetings with the vendor
0/2000 characters

Save Cancel