ASHRM CPHRM Exam - Topic 1 Question 9 Discussion

According to Health Care Risk Management standards established by ASHRM and the American Hospital Association Certification Center, investigation of a liability claim requires careful evaluation of both clinical and legal components. Determining the applicable standard of care is essential to assess whether the provider's actions met accepted professional practice. This typically involves review of medical records, consultation with clinical experts, and comparison to established guidelines or customary practices within the specialty.

Assessing applicable legal principles is also critical. This includes analysis of duty, breach, causation, and damages, as well as jurisdiction-specific statutes of limitation, comparative negligence standards, and evidentiary considerations. Understanding the legal framework allows the risk manager to evaluate exposure and advise counsel appropriately.

Providing a root cause analysis to the insurance company may compromise privilege protections, depending on jurisdiction and policy structure. RCA documents are often protected under peer review or patient safety statutes and should not be disclosed without legal guidance. Obtaining an incident report from the claimant is not appropriate, as internal incident reports are generated by the organization and are not requested from claimants.

Claims and litigation objectives emphasize structured legal and clinical evaluation. Therefore, determining the standard of care and assessing applicable legal principles are required investigative steps.